From Side Stream to Product
Three articles of technology, one simple question: what do you actually make with it?
In our experience, upcycled ingredients succeed in one of three roles:
- A functional replacer: for egg, fibre, colour or part of the flour.
- A nutritional upgrade: for protein, fibre or minerals.
- The hero of a new concept: a recognisable product with a story.
Each role asks for a different formulation strategy and a different business case.
Matching side stream to product
| Side stream | Main role | Watch-outs | Products where it fits |
| Rework dough / baked residues | Functional, cost | pH, age, microbiology, consistency | Same product, rotary-moulded biscuits, crumbs and coatings |
| Brewer's spent grain | Fibre, moistness, story | Gluten dilution, crumbliness, wet logistics | Sandwich bread, crackers, flatbreads, digestives |
| Plant-drink residues | Fibre, protein, story | Moisture, shelf life, variation | Bars, bread, biscuits, fillings |
| Green banana flour | Gluten-free starch, resistant starch | Water binding, hygroscopic biscuits | Gluten-free biscuits, crackers, pancake and cake mixes |
| Sunflower protein | Protein, water binding | Colour at alkaline pH | Protein bread, waffles, dark biscuits |
| Potato protein | Egg replacement | Cost, dosage | Egg-free cake and sponge |
| Yeast protein | Egg replacement or enrichment | Grade choice, upcycled vs fermented | Cakes, high-protein bread and crackers |
Claims: the numbers that decide the label
Under EU Regulation 1924/2006 (EUR-Lex):
- Source of fibre: at least 3 g fibre per 100 g, or 1.5 g per 100 kcal.
- High fibre: at least 6 g fibre per 100 g, or 3 g per 100 kcal.
- Source of protein: at least 12% of energy from protein.
- High protein: at least 20% of energy from protein.
- Source of a mineral: at least a significant amount of that mineral, in practice 15% of the reference intake per 100 g for most solid foods.
Make these thresholds the starting point of the formulation. Calculate backwards from the claim to the dosage, then test whether dough, crumb and colour can carry it. Side streams often bring minerals along. That can open a mineral claim, but only if you calculate it per 100 g of the final product and confirm it with analysis. "Upcycled" is not a regulated nutrition claim; communicate it carefully and factually.
The business case in three questions
- What does it replace, and at what price? Flour, egg, fibre or colour each have a very different price benchmark. Replacing egg or a branded fibre is a stronger case than replacing flour.
- What does it add that a buyer or consumer will pay for? A claim, a cleaner label, a local partnership or a recognisable product.
- Can it scale? Supply volume, batch consistency, storage and dosing on the line. A wet side stream that works in a pilot bakery may not work at industrial line speeds.
What our own projects taught us
- Rework became manageable the moment it got a pH limit and a first-in-first-out rule.
- Spent grain moved from flour substitute to product concept when the dosage was set by the fibre claim.
- Plant-drink residues showed that stabilisation comes before formulation.
- Green banana flour reached 40% of the flour on a rotary moulder, step by step, one change at a time.
- In egg-free cake, potato protein earned its place and sunflower protein did not.
- In egg replacement, the foaming protein and the gelling protein are often two different ones.
The common thread: start from the product and the claim, then choose the side stream, not the other way round.
Learn this in practice: Explore our open courses on the Bakery Academy training page: Bread, Cake, Cookies & Biscuits and Reformulation. Each one works through the ingredient–process–product chain that decides whether an upcycled ingredient succeeds.
Upcycling you can measure. Sustainability you can bake.
Need to know more? Feel free to contact us!
Post a Comment
Please login to post a comment.
Login